Read here

The navy of the American revolution; its administration, its policy, and its achievements

Charles Oscar Paullin · 1906 · Scanned text · Free in the US

110,630 words · about 7 h 45 min to read

Period artwork: Interior of the Bodleian Library, 1845
About this edition

Scanned text — may contain errors · view original scans

Free in the US: this text is in the public domain in the United States; it may still be in copyright elsewhere.

Licence: PD · Library of Congress states the book is in the public domain and free to use and reuse (https://data.labs.loc.gov/digitized-books/README.html); published 1906, public domain asserted for the US only · Library of Congress, Selected Digitized Books (https://www.loc.gov/item/06042974); text via the Common Pile (CC BY 4.0 compilation, per-document rights preserved)

Text from Library of Congress, read from page scans by OCR and set out for reading on screen; no words of the book are rewritten or summarized. How RedLectern is built

About this book

Author
Charles Oscar Paullin
Language
English
Published
1906
Length
110,630 words · about 7 h 45 min
Sections
33 reader sections
Text
Scanned text, read from page scans by OCR; may contain errors
Rights
Public domain in the United States

 

Contents (33)
  1. Preface about 4 min
  2. Chapter I. — The Naval Committee. The need in 1775 for an army and for a under 1 min
  3. Chapter II. — The Fleets of Washington and Arnold. Fitting out of the '' Hannah " 61 under 1 min
  4. Chapter III. — The Organization of the Marine Committee. The maritime interests of New England 79 about 1 min
  5. Chapter IV. — The Work of the Navy Boards and the Marine Committee. Lack of system in the Naval Department of the Revolution 104 about 1 min
  6. Chapter V. — The Conditions of the Continental Naval Service. The recent revolution in navies and naval conditions 141 under 1 min
  7. Chapter VI. — Movements of the Continental Fleet under the Marine Committee. Work of the fleet of a non-military under 1 min
  8. Chapter VII. — The Board of Admiralty. Defects of the Marine Committee 181 about 1 min
  9. Chapter VIII. — The Secretary of Marine and the Agent of Marine. The two factions during the Revolution 210 about 1 min
  10. Chapter IX. — Naval Duties of American Representatives in Foreign Countries. Mutual interests of the United States under 1 min
  11. Chapter X. — Naval Duties of American Representatives in Foreign Countries about 2 min
  12. Chapter XII. — The Navy of Connecticut. The Revolutionary government of Connecticut 354 about 1 min
  13. Chapter XIV. — The Navy of Virginia. Lord Dunmore's movements in Virginia, 1775 396 about 1 min
  14. Chapter XV.— The Navy of South Carolina. First naval enterprises of South Carolina 418 about 1 min
  15. Chapter XVI. — The Minor Navies of the Southern States. Organs of naval administration in about 1 min
  16. Chapter XVII. — The Minor Navies of the Northern States. British depredations in Rhode Island about 1 min
  17. Chapter I The Naval Committee about 28 min
  18. Chapter II The Fleets Of Washington And Arnold^ about 16 min
  19. Chapter III The Organization Of The Marine Committee about 23 min
  20. Chapter IV The Work Of The Navy Boards And " The Marine Committee about 34 min
  21. Chapter V The Conditions Of The Continental Naval Service about 19 min
  22. Chapter VI Movements Of The Continental about 19 min
  23. Chapter VII The Board Of Admiralty about 27 min
  24. Chapter VIII The Secretary Of Marine And The Agent Of Marine about 40 min
  25. Chapter IX Naval Duties Of American Repre- Sentatives In Foreign Countries about 26 min
  26. Chapter X Naval Duties Of American Repre- Sentatives In Foreign Countries about 28 min
  27. Chapter XI The Navy Of Massachusetts about 38 min
  28. Chapter XII The Navy Of Connecticut about 17 min
  29. Chapter XIII The Navy Of Pennsylvania about 22 min
  30. Chapter XIV The Navy Of Virginia about 41 min
  31. Chapter XVI The Minor Navies Of The Southern States about 20 min
  32. Chapter XVII The Minor Navies Of The Northern States about 39 min
  33. Index about 15 min

Continue:

Preface

Several narrative accounts of the navy of the American Revolution have been written. These usually form the introductory part of a history of the American Navy since 1789. The earliest of these accounts is that of Thomas Clark, published in 1814, and probably the best that of James Fenimore Cooper, first printed in 1839. Later narratives are rather more popular than Cooper's. Many sources of information, which were not accessible to the earlier writers, and were not much used by the later, were drawn upon in the writing of this book. Moreover, the information that is here presented is of a somewhat different sort from that of previous writers; and the method of treatment is new.

This book is written from the point of view of the naval administrators; hitherto, historians have written from the point of view of the naval officers. Their narratives treat almost exclusively of the doings at sea, the movements of armed vessels, and the details of sea fights. They have the advantage of dealing primarily with picturesque, and sometimes dramatic, events. Their accounts, however, lack unity, since

Preface they consist of a series of detached incidents.

In the first place an attempt has been here made to restore the naval administrative machinery of the Revolution. The center of this narrative is the origin, organization, and work of naval committees, secretaries of marine, navy boards, and naval agents. Next, inasmuch as the men who served as naval executives administered the laws relating to naval affairs, and indeed often prepared these laws before their adoption by the legislative authorities, it was thought best to give a fairly complete resume of the naval legislation of the Revolution. Those laws with which the naval administrators were chiefly concerned have received most attention. The legislation with reference to prize courts and privateering has been treated more briefly. As the privateers do not, properly speaking, form a part of the Revolutionary navy, no attempt to write their history has been made. In order that the subject may be seen in its true relations, some statistics and other interesting facts concerning this industry have, however, been introduced. An account of the State Navies is now given for the first time.

Since naval committees, navy boards, and naval agents issued written orders to the naval commanders prescribing the time place, and manner of their cruises, it has seemed logical and proper to consider the naval policy of the administrators, and the

Preface 7

movements of the armed vessels. So detailed an account of naval movements, as would be given by those writers who proceed from the point of view of the doings of the naval officers, would obviously not be expected in this book. My plan has been to describe the various classes of naval movements, to present the sum total of their results, and to give briefly the details of a few typical cruises and sea fights. The cruises of the American vessels were much alike; they were minor affairs, and many of them scarcely merit individual treatment.

It is evident that one who proposes to write the history of the navy of the American Revolution from the point of view which I have described, will not only avoid excessive detail in respect to individual naval achievements, but will be particularly determined not to allow their brilliancy or their dramatic quality to fix the amount of detail with which each shall be narrated. For instance, several historians have been inclined to dwell at some length upon the brilliant and picturesque achievements of John Paul Jones. Sometimes they have devoted more than one-third of their narratives of the Continental navy to this hero, undoubtedly the greatest naval officer of the Revolution. As a result, the pictures which they have presented are somewhat distorted, and many brave sea officers have had scant justice done their gallant services.

8 Preface

An attempt is made in this book to present a better balanced narrative, and to make a j lister estimate of the work of the Revolutionary navy. The scope and method of treatment adopted by the author has compelled a certain economy of phrase, precision of statement, and sharpness of outline.

I am very grateful to the many persons who have assisted me. Space does not permit me to thank each of them by name. I am under special obligations to the librarians and officials of the Library of Congress, the Library of the Department of the Navy, the Bureau of Rolls and Library of the Department of State, the State Library of Massachusetts, the Office of the Massachusetts State Archives, the Boston Public Library, the Boston Athenaeum, the Library of Harvard University, the State Library of Rhode Island, the Rhode Island Historical Society, the State Library of Connecticut, the Connecticut Historical Society, the Pennsylvania Historical Society, the State Library of Virginia, the Virginia Historical Society, the Office of the Secretary of State of South Carolina, the Charleston (South Carolina) Public Library, and the Library of the University of Chicago. Far more than to any one else, I am indebted to Professor John Franklin Jameson, Director of the Department of Historical Research in the Carnegie Institution of Washington. I have had the advantage of Professor Jameson's extensive

Preface 9

knowledge of bibliography, his fruitful suggestions as to treatment, and his painstaking care in reading and criticising my manuscript. Parts of the narrative, somewhat popularized, have appeared in the Proceedings of the United States Naval Institute and the Sewanee Review.

C. O. P.

Washington, D. C.

March 1, 1906.

Contents

THE CONTINENTAL NAVY

Chapter I. — The Naval Committee. The need in 1775 for an army and for a

navy 31

Agitation for a navy outside of Congress 32

Agitation for a navy in Congress 34

The first naval legislation 35

Appointment of the Naval Committee 38

First work of the Naval Committee. ... 38

Reconstitution of the Naval Committee 38 John Adams's description of the Naval

Committee 39

The organization and decline of the Naval Committee 40

Growth in Congress of naval sentiment 41 Naval legislation under the Naval Committee 42

The procuring of a fleet 51

The appointment of officers 52

The first naval expedition 55

Resume of the work of the Naval Com-

mittpp eO

Chapter II. — The Fleets of Washington and Arnold. Fitting out of the '' Hannah " 61

Fitting out of Washington's "Boston

fleet" 62

Washington's opinion of his commanders 64

Services rendered by Washington's

''Boston fleet" 65

Broughton and Selman's raid on Prince

Edward island 66

The disposition of Washington's prizes 67

The delay in bringing them to trial. ... 68 History of the fleet after the evacuation

of Boston 69

Washington's " New York fleet " 70

Beginning of the fleet on lakes Champlain and George 71

Its increase in the summer of 1776 72

The work of Benedict Arnold 73

The British fleet on the Lakes 76

The battle of Lake Champlain, October

11-13, 1776 77

Results of the naval campaign on the

Lakes ; 77

Chapter III. — The Organization of the Marine Committee. The maritime interests of New England 79

Naval enterprise in Rhode Island 80

The naval situation in Congress, 1775-76 81

The Rhode Island instructions 81

Contents

The debate in Congress thereon 82

Postponement of action on instructions . 83 Favorable action by Congress, December 11, 1775 85

Decision of Congress to build thirteen

frigates 85

Appointment of the Marine Committee 86 The Marine Committee absorbs the Naval Committee 87

The organization and pay of the Marine Committee 87

Its chairmen 88

Other valuable members 90

Naval agents for building the Continental frigates 90

Prize agents 93

Continental agents 95

Aid rendered the Marine Committee ... 95

Navy Board at Philadelphia 96

Navy Board at Boston 97

Designations of the boards 99

The organization of the boards 100

The personnel of the boards 101

Salaries 102

Enumeration of the principal agents of

the Marine Committee 103

Minor agents 103

Chapter IV. — The Work of the Navy Boards and the Marine Committee. Lack of system in the Naval Department of the Revolution 104

Examples 105

Work and duties of the navy boards. . 107 Men and materials needed in building a

ship 110

Provisions needed in fitting out a ship 112 Division of labor among the naval commissioners 112

The heavy work of the Boston Board. . 113 Two-fold duties of the Marine Committee 115

Administrative duties of the Marine

Committee 116

Naval uniform 117

Communications of the Marine Committee 118

Reports of the Marine Committee 120

Naval legislation under the Marine Committee 121

Naval appointments and promotions. . 123

Relative rank 125

Captures and the sharing of prizes 126

Naval pay 128

Naval pensions 129

Courts-martial and courts of enquiry. . 131

Important naval trials 133

The case of Commodore Esek Hopkins 134 Provision for the fleet of Count D'Est-

aing 139

The Marine Committee as a consular

bureau 139

Chapter V. — The Conditions of the Continental Naval Service. The recent revolution in navies and naval conditions 141

Constancy of the principles of naval

strategy 143

Maritime conditions in America in 1775,

Difficulties in procuring seamen during

the Revolution 144

The privateers of the Revolution 147

State navies 152

The naval defence of America 153

Naval stations of the Americans 154

Naval stations of the British 155

Comparison of the British and American navies 156

Weakness of the American navies 159

Diffusion of authority in naval administration 160

Chapter VI. — Movements of the Continental Fleet under the Marine Committee. Work of the fleet of a non-military

character 161

Classification of military operations . . . 162

Primary naval operations 163

Enumeration of secondary operations. 164

Defence of American commerce 164

Cooperation with the army 166

The striKing of the enemy's lines of

communication 167 i6 Contents

Commerce-destroying 169

The threatening and attacking of the

enemy's coasts 173

A naval plan of Robert Morris 174

The Marine Committee and its plans. . 176

Success and failure of the navj; 177

The navy of the Revolution and of the

Spanish- American war 179

Chapter VII. — The Board of Admiralty. Defects of the Marine Committee 181

Criticism of the administration of Congress 182

A new system of Executives 184

Criticism of the Naval Department by

Washington and Jay 184

Establishment of a Board of Admiralty,

Powers and duties of the Board of Admiralty 188

Salaries 189

Selection of commissioners of Admiralty 190

Francis Lewis and William Ellery 193

Congress and the Board of Admiralty . 194

Work of the Board of Admiralty 195

Decrease in naval machinery 195

Reports of the Board of Admiralty 196

Naval legislation under the Board of

Admiralty 197

The granting of naval commissions by

the states 201

The American navy and British models 202

Court of appeals for prize cases 203

Contents ly

The fleet under the Board of Admiralty 203 Embarrassments of the Board of Admiralty 204

Success and failure of the fleet 205

Discontinuance of the Board of Admiralty 208

Defects of the Board of Admiralty. . . . 209

Chapter VIII. — The Secretary of Marine and the Agent of Marine. The two factions during the Revolution 210

Supremacy of the ''dispersive schoor\ 211

The ''concentrative schooF' in 1780. ... 212

Agitation for administrative reform.. . . 213 The success of the ''concentrative

school" 214

Establishment of the office of Secretary

of Marine, February, 1781 216

Duties of the Secretary of Marine 216

Appointment of McDougall as Secretary of Marine 217

Failure to obtain a Secretary of Marine... 218

Robert Morris and the naval business. 218 Reorganization of the Naval Department 220

The Agent of Marine 223

Robert Morris as Agent of Marine 226

The organization of the Naval Department under Morris 227

Reports of the Agent of Marine 228

Naval legislation under the Agent of

Marine 228

Contents

The court-martialing of three seamen. . 230 Morris and the control of the fleet. . . . 234

The strength of the navy 235

Success and failure of the fleet 235

The cruise of the ^'Alliance/' 1782-1783 236 The capture of the ''Trumbull" by the

Attempts of Morris to increase the navy 239 Morris's views after the treaty of peace 244 Congress goes out of the naval business 245

Settling of the naval accounts 245

Disposing of the naval vessels 247

Retirement of the Agent of Marine. . . . 250 The end of the naval business 250

Chapter IX. — Naval Duties of American Representatives in Foreign Countries. Mutual interests of the United States

and France 252

Duties of the Naval Office at Paris. . . . 252

Personnel of the Naval Office 254

Communication with the Naval Office.. 255

Agents of the Naval Office 256

Appointment and recommendation of

officers 257

The purchase and construction of vessels 261

The fitting out of vessels 265

The trial of prize cases 266

American prisoners 267

Breaches of neutrality 273

Miscellaneous duties 274

The Naval Office a channel of naval intelligence 276

Naval plans of the Naval Office 276

Plan of the Committee of Foreign Affairs 278

Chapter X. — Naval Duties of American Representatives in Foreign Countries

Continued.

Work of the Naval Office in 1777 281

Attempts to obtain the freedom of French ports 282

The first prizes of the ''Reprisal". ... 283

Difficulties between the English and the French governments 284

The American Commissioners and the French government 285

The cruise of the ''Reprisal," February, 1777 286

The cruise of Conyngham in the "Surprise" 287

The cruise of the "Reprisal," "Lexington," and "Dolphin" 287

Strained relations between the Commissioners and the French Court 289

The cruise of Conyngham in the "Revenge" 290

Departure of the "Reprisal" and the "Lexington" 291

Naval movements in 1778 292

The cruise of Captain Jones in the "Ranger" 293

The Naval Office at Paris, 1779-1780 . . 294 John Paul Jones and Peter Landais . . 294 Plan for an expedition against England 295 The cruise of Captain Jones in the " Bon

Homme Richard" ■ 295

Dispute between Jones and Landais... . 298

Their departure for America 300

The trials of Franklin 300

Work of the Naval Office, 1781-1783. 301 Thomas Barclay, consul and commissioner 302

John Paul Jones, agent for settling accounts 303

Naval stations in the West Indies 305

Duties and work of the commercial

agent at Martinique 305

Naval affairs on the Mississippi 307

Oliver Pollock and Galvez 307

Pollock and privateers 308

Pollock and the ''Rebecca" 308

The ''West Florida" 310

THE STATE NAVIES

Chapter XL — The Navy of Massachusetts.

The state craft 315

Naval administration in the states. . . . 316

The problems of naval warfare 317

Military situation in Massachusetts,

1775 318

Action of the Provincial Congress 318

Massachusetts seaports ask for naval

aid 319

Act establishing privateering and prize

courts, November 1, 1775 320

Subsequent naval activities of the General court, 1775 323

The fitting out of a fleet, 1776 324

Naval legislation, 1776 325

Remodelling of the law of November 1,

1775 327

Orders to naval officers — a sample. . . . 328 Establishment of a Board of War, October, 1776 329

Duties of the Board of War 330

A new naval establishment 333

Naval rules and regulations 334

Launching of the ''Protector" 336

Naval administration, 1779-1783 337

Massachusetts privateers 339

The cruises of the state fleet 341

Cooperation of state vessels and privateers 344

The engagements of the state vessels —

a sample 345

The Penobscot expedition 347

Losses of the state fleet 352

The end of the navy 353

Chapter XII. — The Navy of Connecticut. The Revolutionary government of Connecticut 354

Fitting out of the ''Minerva" and the

Failure and discharge of the "Minerva" 357

The "Defence" and the "OHver Cromwell" 358

The building of three row-galleys . . . , . 360 Naval duties of the Governor and the

Council of Safety 360

Naval agents 361

New London and Nathaniel Shaw, jr. . 362

BushnelFs submarine boat 363

Privateers and prize courts 364

Naval pensions 366

Naval rules and regulations 366

A new naval estabhshment, 1779 366

Cruises of the navy 367

Losses of the navy 369

Warfare of whale-boats on Long Island Sound 370

Chapter XIIL — The Navy of Pennsylvania.

Objects of naval enterprise in Pennsylvania 373

The fleet of galleys 373

Rules and regulations 375

The "Montgomery" 375

Strength of the navy, August, 1776.. . 376

Naval uniforms and flag 377

Organs of naval administration 377

Commodores of the navy 378

Naval pay and the sharing of prizes. . 380

The Pennsylvania Navy Board 381

Work of the Navy Board 382

The navy in 1777 383

Services rendered by the fleet 383

The campaign on the Delaware, 1777-

1778 384

Trials for desertion 386

The fleet, April- July, 1778. 388

Sale of the fleet and dismissal of the

Navy Board 388

The '^General Greene,^' 1779 390

Naval legislation 391

Commissioners for the defence of the

Delaware 393

The ''Hyder Ally" and "Washington" 394 The end of the navy 395

Chapter XIV. — The Navy of Virginia. Lord Dunmore's movements in Virginia, 1775 396

Authorization of a navy, December,

1775 396

Work of the Committee of Safety 397

The " Potomac River fleet" 398

The Virginia Navy Board 398

Duties of the Navy Board 399

The location of shipyards 400

Naval manufactories and magazines. . . 401

James Maxwell, naval agent 401

Naval officers 401

Courts of Admiralty 403

The vessels of the Virginia navy 405

Condition and services of the nav}-,

1775-1779 407

Losses of the navy, 1775-1779 408

The Board of War and the Naval Commissioner 408

The Commissioner of the Navy 409

Military situation in the South in 1780 410

Naval legislation, 1780 411

The raid of Arnold and PhiUips, 1781. 413

The navy at Yorktown 415

Dismissal of the officers, seamen, and

Commissioner 415

Virginia's defence of Chesapeake Bay,

1782-1783 415

The end of the navy 416

Chapter XV.— The Navy of South Carolina. First naval enterprises of South Carolina 418

Events of September, 1775 419

The "Defence" 420

Work of the Provincial Congress, November, 1775 420

Work of the Committee of Safety, December, 1775 421

The mission of Cochran 421

Naval legislation, February-March, 1776 422

The Constitution of 1776 423

Naval legislation, April, 1776 423

South Carolina Navy Board . 424

Work and organization of the Navy

Board 424

Naval legislation, 1777-1778 427

Services rendered by the South Carolina navy, 1776-1779 429

The "Randolph" and the State fleet. . . 430 The campaign against Charleston, 1779-

1780 431

The navy in 1781 and 1783 434

Commodore Gillon and the ''South Carolina" 435

Gillon in Europe 436

The "South Carolina" in European

waters 436

The e:^pedition against the Bahamas. . 438 The "South Carolina" at Philadelphia. 439

Capture of the "South Carolina" 439

Settlement of the Luxembourg claims. . 439

Chapter XVI. — The Minor Navies of the Southern States. Organs of naval administration in

Maryland 441

Work of the Maryland Provincial Convention, 1776 441

Work of the Maryland Committee of

Maryland vessels 442

Recruiting of the navy 443

Naval officers -. . 443

Court of Admiralty 444

Maryland privateers 444

Sale of naval vessels, 1779 444

Naval conditions, 1779-1783 445

Acts for the defence of the Chesapeake 445

Transporting of the Continental army. 446

British depredations, 1782-1783 446

Commissioners for the defence of the

Bay 447

Services rendered by the Maryland

navy 448

The Battle of the Barges 449

End of the Maryland navy 451

The navy of North Carolina, December,

The '^Washington," ^'Pennsylvania

Farmer," and ''King Tammany".. . . 452

The defence of Ocracoke Inlet 454

Services of the "Caswell" 456

North Carolina admiralty courts and

Georgia's first naval enterprise 459

Naval preparations 460

Georgia's galleys 460

Georgia's prize court 462

Chapter XVII. — The Minor Navies of the Northern States. British depredations in Rhode Island

1775 463

Naval operations . . . .^ 463

The "Katy" and "Washington" 464

The ''Washington" and ''Spitfire'*- galleys 465

Organs of naval administration 466

Prize court and privateers 467

An attempted naval increase, 1777 468

Cooperation of Rhode Island with Congress, 1778-1779 468

The "Pigot" and the "Argo'' 469

The "Rover" 470

Naval preparations in New York 471

New York's naval establishment 472

Washington and the New York vessels 473

Services of the New York fleet 474

Additional facts about naval affairs in

New York 475

New Hampshire and the Penobscot expedition 476

New Hampshire privateers and prize

court 476

Naval suggestions of New Jersey 477

APPENDICES

A bibliography 481

A list of commissioned officers in the

Continental Navy 506

A list of commissioned officers in the

Continental Marine Corps 512

A list of armed vessels 516 \

Chapter I The Naval Committee

The history of the Continental navy covers a period of ten years, extending from 1775 to 1785. During this time the Continental Congress made many experiments in naval legislation and devised several organs of naval administration. The first of these organs, with whose origin and work this chapter is concerned, was the Naval Committee. It lasted for only a few months. Its lineal successors, each of which will be duly considered, w^ere the Marine Committee, the Board of Admiralty, and the Agent of Marine. These four executive organs, for the most part, administered the Continental navy. Certain odds and ends of the naval business, however, fell to the commander-in-chief of the army and his officers, and to the American representatives in foreign countries. The second chapter will treat of the fleets of the army, and the closing chapters of the narrative of the Continental navy will consider the naval services of our representatives in foreign lands.

In maritime countries the military service is generally ambidextrous. Whether the army or navy is first brought into play at the opening of a war depends upon various circumstances. The presence of a British army at Boston, already on colonial soil, when the American Revolution broke out early in 1775, naturally led to the immediate organization of an army by the colonists. The need of a navy was at this time not quite so insistent. Moreover, the building, or even the purchase, of an armed fleet required more time than did the raising of an army, which was rendered comparatively easy by the previous training of the colonists in the local militia. Nevertheless, since both countries engaged in the war w^ere maritime, the creating of a navy could not long be delayed.

The reader recollects that by the middle of 1775 the battles of Lexington, Concord, and Bunker Hill had been fought, a Continental army had been organized, and Washington had been made commander-in-chief. Outside of Congress the agitation in behalf of a Continental navy had begun. That the first suggestions and advances for a navy should come from New England, where the concrete problems of the defence of her ports and coasts were being faced, was to be expected. One of the first men to make such suggestions was Josiah Quincy of Massachusetts. On July 11, 1775, he wrote to John Adams in Philadelphia that the best method of securing the coastwise navigation of the colonies was by row-galleys. He then continued: '^As the whole Continent is so firmly united, why not a Number of Vessels of War be fitted out and judiciously stationed, so as to intercept and prevent any supplies going to our Enemies ; and consequently, unless they can make an Impression inland, they must leave the Country or starve."^ The first formal movement in behalf of a Continental navy came from Rhode Island, which state w'as during the summer of 1775 suffering serious annoyances from the British ships. On August 26 her legislature instructed the Rhode Island delegates to the Continental Congress to use their influence at the ensuing session of Congress to obtain a fleet for the protection of the colonies.^ On September 2, 1775, Washington, in order to prevent reinforcements from reaching the enemy at Boston, instructed Nicholson Broughton to proceed in the schooner ''Hannah" on a cruise against the British transports.^

1. Manuscript Letters of John Adams, lodged with the Massachusetts Historical Society by Mr. Charles Francis Adams, who kindly permitted the writer to see them.

2. See Chapter III, The Organization of the Marine Committee.

3. See Chapter II, The Fleets of Washington and Arnold. After a thorough investigation and study of the sources of the early history of the Continental navy, I am compelled to reject many of the statements and conclusions found in Chapter II, Volume I, of Augustus

That the question of providing a Continental navy would come up during the fall session of Congress was certain. The arguments in its behalf, which were made almost unanimously later in the session, must have been on the lips of several of the members when they assembled in Philadelphia in September: an army had been organized, why not a navy? The situation of the combatants, separated by the great Atlantic highway; and their character, one a great naval and commercial power, and the other with maritime interests by no means inconsiderable, would necessarily make the impending struggle in no small part a naval one. America had seacoasts and seaports to be defended, a coastwise navigation to be secured, and above all commercial and diplomatic communications with foreign powers to be kept open. These communications were a jugular vein, whose severing would mean death to the United Colonies. The urgent and specific calls for armed vessels, which were being made, must be met at once. Had not America conveniently at hand materials for ships, and abundant men who had the ''habit of the sea"?

In the early months of the session there certainly would arise opposition to the new military project. The inertia and conserv-

C. Buell's book, Paul Jones, Founder of the American Navy.

atism of some of the members would set them against so great an innovation. To others the fitting out of a fleet, at a time when the length, seriousness, and meaning of the war with the motherland were but half unveiled, would seem an unwise and hasty action.

The question of procuring a fleet of armed vessels was first brought to the attention of Congress on October 3, 1775, when the Rhode Island members presented their instructions, an account of which will be given in a succeeding chapter.^ It is sufficient for present purposes to say that until December the Rhode Island instructions had little other result beyond crystallizing and clarifying opinion on naval affairs by means of the debates which they caused in Congress.

On October 5 sundry letters from London were laid before the Congress and read. They conveyed the intelligence of 'Hhe sailing of two north country built brigs, of no force, from England, on the 11th of August last, loaded with arms, powder, and other stores, for Quebec, without convoy." Congress at once saw the importance of capturing these two vessels, in order both to deprive the British of these stores and to obtain them for the Continental army around Boston, which sorely needed all the munitions of war it could get. A motion was

1. See Chapter III, The Organization of the Marine Committee.

therefore made that a committee of three be appointed to prepare a plan for intercepting the two brigs, and that it "proceed on this business immediately."^ John Adams in his autobiography says that the opposition to this motion was "very loud and vehement," and included some of his own colleagues, and also especially Edward Rutledge of South Carolina. It seems to have been recognized that the carrying of the motion would be the initial step in the establishment of a Continental navy. Such an undertaking its opponents declared, with a greater display of rhetoric than judgment, was the "most wild, visionary, mad project that ever had been imagined. It was an infant taking a mad bull by his horns; and what was more profound and remote, it was said it would ruin the character and corrupt the morals of all our seamen. It would make them selfish, piratical, mercenary, bent wholly upon plunder, etc., etc." The friends of the motion, in colors equally glowing, set forth "the great advantages of distressing the enemy, supplying ourselves, and beginning a system of maritime and naval operations." On the taking of the vote the motion passed in the affirmative; and ac-

1. Journals of Continental Congress, October 5, 1775. Waite, H. E., Origin of American Navy, 1-5, containing letters of John Adams, Elbridge Gerry, and John Langdon, written in 1813.

cording to John Adams's recollection, he, John Langdon of New Hampshire, and Silas Deane of Connecticut, 'Hhree members who had expressed much zeal in favor of the motion," composed the committee.^

A little later on the same day this committee reported; and thereupon Congress decided to write a letter to Washington directing him to obtain from the Council of Massachusetts two of that state's cruisers, and to despatch them on the errand of intercepting the two supply ships. It also directed that letters be written to the governors of Connecticut and Rhode Island asking for the loan of some of their armed vessels, which were to be sent on the same mission. "The committee appointed to prepare a plan for intercepting the two vessels bound to Canada " made another report on the 6th, which was ordered to lie on the table "for the perusal of the members."^ This report was acted upon on October 13, when Congress decided to fit out two armed vessels, one of ten and the other of fourteen guns, to cruise three months to the

1. Works of John Adams, III, 7, 8. I have accepted the account of this debate as found in John Adams's autobiography, although it is possible that writing many years after its occurrence Adams may have confused it with the debate of October 7 on the Rhode Island resolutions. — Works of John Adams, I, 1S7.

eastward for the purpose of intercepting the enemy's transports laden with warhke stores and other suppUes. A committee consisting of Silas Deane, John Langdon, and Christopher Gadsden of South Carolina was appointed to estimate the expense which would be incurred in fitting out the two vessels.^

In four days this new committee reported an estimate, which was unsatisfactory and was recommitted.^ When it again reported on October 30, two more vessels, one to mount not more than twenty and the other not more than thirty-six guns, were ordered to be prepared for sea, and 'Ho be emploj^ed in such manner, for the protection and defence of the United Colonies, as the Congress shall direct." ''It should be noted that the two vessels for which provision was now made were to engage in the defence of the colonies, and not merely in the interception of transports, an indication of an advance in the naval policy of Congress. '• Four additional members were now added to the committee, Stephen Hopkins of Rhode Island, Joseph Hewes of North Carolina, R. H. Lee of Virginia, and John Adams of Massachusetts.^ This reconstituted committee

1. Journals of Continental Congress, October 13, 1775. The armament of the second vessel was not determined until October 30, 1775.

3. Ibid., October 30, 1775. John Adams, in his Notes on Debates for October 30, 1775,

I composed of seven members was sometimes called "the committee for fitting out armed vessels/' occasionally the "Marine Committee," but most frequently the "Naval Committee." It secured for its use a room in a public house in Philadelphia, and in order that there should be no conflict between its meetings and those of Congress, it fixed its hours from six in the evening until the close of its business. Its sessions were sometimes pleasantly continued, even until midnight, by conversational diversions, marked by a rich flow of soul, history, poetry, wine, and Jamaica rum.

The opening of the book is shown; the full text loads in the reader.

Loading the full text…