A narrative of the mutiny, on board the ship Globe, of Nantucket, in the Pacific Ocean, Jan. 1824.

Front matter

A

NARRATIVE

OF THE

Introduction

Formerly whales were principally taken in the North Seas : the largest were generally found about Spitzbergen or Greenland, some of them measuring ninety feet in length. At the commencement of the hazardous enterprise of killing whales, before they had been disturbed by man,, they were so numerous in the bays and harbors, that when taken the blubber was for the most part boiled into oil upon the contiguous coast.

The pure oil and whalebone were only preserved in those days; consequently a ship could carry home the product of a greater number of whales than a ship of the same size now can. Indeed, so plentiful were the whales in those seas, and taken with such facility, that the ships employed were not sufficient to carry home the oil and bone, and other ships were often sent to ix

Introduction* bring home the surplus quantity. But the coasts of these countries were soon visited by ships from Denmark, Hamburg and Holland, as well as from England; and from frequently being killed in the shoal water near the coasts, the whales gradually receded from the shores, and have since been found only in deeper water, and at a much greater distance from the land.

In the earlier stages of the whale fishery, of which we are now treating, the ships were generally on the whaling waters early in May, and whether successful or not they were obliged to commence their return by the succeeding August, to avoid the early accumulation of ice in those seas. But it not unfrequently happened, that ships procured and returned with a cargo in the months of June and July, making a voyage only about three months, whereas a voyage to the Pacific Ocean is now often protracted to three years!

Among the early whalers it was customary to have six boats to a ship, and six men to a boat, besides the harpooner. What at that time was x

Introduction.

considered an improved method in killing whales, consisted in discharging the harpoon from a kind of swivel; but it was soon found to be attended with too much inconvenience to be much practised, and the muscular arms and steady nerves of the harpooner have ever since performed the daring duty, of first striking the whale. The ropes attached to the harpoon used to be about 200 fathoms in length, and some instances occurred, that all the lines belonging to six boats were fastened together, and ran out by one whale, the animal descending in nearly a perpendicular line from the surface. Instead of going prepared to bring home a shipload of oil, it was customary to bring only the blubber, and instead of trying the oil out and putting it into casks on board, the fat of the whale was cut up into suitable pieces, pressed hard in tubs carried out for the purpose, and in this position was the return cargo received at home.

Of so great consequence was the whale fishery considered to Great Britain, that a bounty of 40s. for every ton, when the ship was 200 tons, of xi

Introduction, upwards, was given to the crews of ships engaged in that business in the Greenland seas, under certain conditions. But this bounty was found to draw too largely upon the treasury; and while the subject was under consideration in the British Parliament, in 1786, it was stated that the sums which that country had paid in bounties to the Greenland fishers, amounted to 1,265,461 pounds sterling. Six thousand seamen were employed in that fishery, and each cost the government £13 10s. per annum. The great encouragement given to that branch of commerce, caused so large a number to engage in it, that the oil market became glutted, and it was found necessary to export considerable quantities.

In 1786, the number of British ships engaged in the whale fishery to Davis's Strait and the Greenland seas was 139, besides 15 from Scotland. In 1787, notwithstanding the bounty had been diminished, the number of English ships was 217, and the following year 222.

The charter right of the island of Nantucket was bought by Thomas Mayhew, of Watertown, xii

Introduction.

of Joseph Ferrick, steward to Lord Sterling, in 1 641 ; and afterwards sold to Tristam Coffin, and his associates, who settled upon it in 1659. On the 10th of May, 1660, Sachems, Wonnock, and Nickannoose, for and in behalf of the nations of the Island in consideration of the sum of £25, conveyed by deed about half of the Island to the first ten purchasers, who afterwards took in other associates.

Whaling from Nantucket was first carried on from the shore in boats. In 1672, James Loper entered into a contract with the inhabitants of the Island, for the purpose of prosecuting the whale fishery, by which it appears that James Loper agreed to be one third in the enterprise; and sundry other people of the Island, the other two thirds, in everything connected with the undertaking. It was further stipulated, that for every whale killed by any one of the contracting party, the town should receive five shillings, and for the encouragement of James Loper, the town granted him ten acres of land in some convenient situation, and liberty for the commonage of

Introduction* three cows, twenty sheep, and one horse, with necessary wood and water for his use, on condition that he should follow the trade of whaling for two years, build upon his land, etc., etc.

Thus it will be seen that the commencement of whaling at Nantucket, was on a very small scale, and practised only along the shores of the Island ; whereas, at this time, our ships leave no seas unexplored in pursuit of these monsters of the deep. We might pursue the subject through the various stages of improvement up to this time, but it would swell this introduction beyond the limits designed. It is proper, however, to observe that the present number of ships employed in the whale fishery from Nantucket, is about 70, averaging about 350 tons each, and manned by about 1,500 seamen.

xiv

THE GLOBE MUTINY.

Chapter I

The ship Globe, on board of which vessel occurred the horrid transactions we are about to relate, belonged to the Island of Nantucket; she was owned by Messrs. C. Mitchell & Co., and other merchants of that place ; and commanded on this voyage by Thomas Worth, of Edgartown, Martha's Vineyard. William Beetle (mate), John Lumbard (2d mate), Nathaniel Fisher, (3d mate), Gilbert Smith (boat steerer), Samuel B. Comstock (boat steerer), Stephen Kidder (seaman), Peter C. Kidder (seaman), Columbus Worth (seaman), Rowland Jones (seaman), John Cleveland, (seaman), Constant Lewis (seaman), Holden Henman (seaman), Jeremiah Ingham (seaman), Joseph Ignasius Prass (sea- *5 man), Cyrus M. Hussey (cooper), Rowland Coffin ( cooper ) , George Comstock ( seaman ) , and William Lay (seaman).

On the 15th day of December, we sailed from lidgartown, on a whaling voyage to the Pacific Ocean, but in working out, having carried away the cross- jack-yard, we returned to port and after having refitted and sent aloft another, we sailed again on the 19th, and on the same day anchored in Holmes' Hole. On the following day a favorable opportunity offering to proceed to sea, we got under way, and after having cleared the land, discharged the pilot, made sail, and performed the necessary duties of stowing the anchors, unbending and coiling away the cables, etc. On the 1st of January, 1823, we experienced a heavy gale from N. W., which was but the first in the catalogue of difficulties we were fated to encounter. As this was our first trial of a seaman's life, the scene presented to our view, "'Mid the howling storm," was one of terrific grandeur, as well as of real danger. But as the ship scudded well, and the wind was fair, she i6 was kept before it, under a close reefed main-topsail and fore-sail, although during the gale, which lasted forty-eight hours, the sea frequently threatened to board us, which was prevented by the skillful management of the helm. On the 9th of January, we made the Cape Verde Islands, bearing S. W., twenty-five miles distant, and on the 17th, crossed the Equator. On the 29th of the same month we saw sperm whales, lowered our boats, and succeeded in taking one ; the blubber of which, when boiled out, yielded us seventy-five barrels of oil. Pursuing our voyage, on the 23d of February we passed the Falkland Islands, and about the 5th of March, doubled the great promontory of South America, Cape Horn, and stood to the Northward.

We saw whales once only before we reached the Sandwich Islands, which we made on the 1st of May, early in the morning. When drawing in with the island of Hawaii about four in the afternoon, the man at the masthead gave notice that he saw a shoal of black M

The Globe Mutiny.

fish on the lee bow ; which we soon found to be canoes on their way to meet us. It falling calm at this time prevented their getting alongside until night-fall, which they did, at a distance of more than three leagues from the land. We received from them a very welcome supply of potatoes, sugar-cane, yams, cocoanuts, bananas, fish, etc., for which we gave them in return, pieces of iron hoop, nails, and similar articles. We stood off and on during the next day, and after obtaining a sufficient supply of vegetables and fruit, we shaped our course for Oahu, at which place we arrived on the following day, and after lying there twenty hours, sailed for the coast of Japan, in company with the whaling ships Palladium of Boston and Pocahontas of Falmouth; from which ships we parted company when two days out. After cruising in the Japan seas several months, and obtaining five hundred and fifty barrels of oil, we again shaped our course for the Sandwich Islands, to obtain a supply of vegetables, etc. While lying at Oahu, six of the men deserted \Z

The Globe Mutiny.

in the night ; two of them having been retaken were put in irons, but one of them having found means to divest himself of his irons, set the other at liberty, and both escaped.

To supply their places, we shipped the following persons, viz. : Silas Payne, John Oliver, Anthony Hanson, a native of Oahu, Wm. Humphries, a black man, and steward, and Thomas Liliston. Having accommodated ourselves with as many vegetables and as much fruit as could be preserved, we again put to sea, fondly anticipating a successful cruise, and a speedy and happy meeting with our friends.

After leaving Oahu we ran to the south of the Equator, and after cruising a short time for whales without much success, we steered for Fannings Island, which lies in lat. 3 0 49/ N., and long. 158 0 29' W. While cruising off this island an event occurred which, whether we consider the want of motives, or the coldblooded and obstinate cruelty with which it was perpetrated, has not often been equalled. We speak of the want of motives, because although i9 some occurrences which we shall mention, had given the crew some ground for dissatisfaction, there had been no abuse or severity which could in the least degree excuse or palliate so barbarous a mode of redress and revenge. During our cruise to Japan the season before, many complaints were uttered by the crew among themselves, with respect to the manner and quantity in which they received their meat, the quantity sometimes being more than sufficient for the number of men, and at others not enough to supply the ship's company; and it is fair to presume that the most dissatisfied deserted the ship at Oahu.

But the reader will no doubt consider it superfluous for us to attempt an unrequired vindication of the conduct of the officers of the Globe, whose aim was to maintain a correct discipline which should result in the furtherance of the voyage and be a benefit to all concerned, more especially when he is informed, that part of the men shipped at Oahu, in the room of the deserters, were abandoned wretches. 20 who frequently were the cause of severe reprimands from the officers, and in one instance one of them received a severe flogging. The reader will also please to bear in mind, that Samuel B. Comstock, the ringleader of the mutiny, was an officer (being a boat-steerer), and as is customary, ate in the cabin. The conduct and deportment of the captain toward this individual, was always decorous and gentlemanly, a proof of intentions long premeditated to destroy the ship. Some of the crew were determined to leave the ship provided she touched at Fannings Island, and we believe had concerted a plan of escape, but of which the perpetration of a deed chilling to humanity, precluded the necessity. We were at this time in company with the ship Lyra, of New Bedford, the captain of which had been on board the Globe during the most of the day, but had returned in the evening to his own ship. An agreement had been made by him with the captain of the Globe, to set a light at midnight as a signal for tacking. It may not be amiss to 21 acquaint the reader of the manner in which whalemen keep watch during the night.

They generally carry three boats, though some carry four, five, and sometimes six; the Globe, however, being of the class carrying three. The captain, mate, and second mate stand no watch, except there is blubber to be boiled; the boatsteerers taking charge of the watch and managing the ship with their respective boat's crews, and in this instance dividing the night into three parts, each taking a third. So it happened that Smith, after keeping the first watch, was relieved by Comstock (whom we shall call by his surname in contradistinction to his brother George), and the waist boat's crew, and the former watch retired below to their berths and hammocks. George Comstock took the helm, and during his trick, received orders from his brother to "keep the ship a good full," swearing that the ship was too nigh the wind. When his time at the helm had expired he took the rattle (an instrument used by whalemen to announce the expiration of the hour, the watch, 22 etc.), and began to shake it, when Comstock came to him, and in the most peremptory manner, ordered him to desist, saying, "If you make the least damn bit of noise I'll send you to hell !" He then lighted a lamp and went into the steerage. George, becoming rattled at this conduct of his unnatural brother, again took the rattle for the purpose of alarming some one; Comstock arrived in time to prevent him, and with threatenings dark and diabolical, so congealed the blood of his trembling brother, that even had he possessed the power of alarming the unconscious and fated victims below, his life would have been the forfeit of his temerity.

Comstock now laid something heavy upon a small work bench near the cabin gangway, which was afterwards found to be a boarding knife. It is an instrument used by whalers to cut the blubber when hoisting it in, is about four feet in length, two or three inches wide, and necessarily kept very sharp and for greater convenience when in use, is two edged, 23

In giving a detail of this chilling transaction, we shall be guided by the description given of it by the younger Comstock, who, as has been observed, was upon the deck at the time, and afterwards learned several particulars from his brother, to whom alone they could have been known. Comstock went down into the cabin, accompanied by Silas Payne, or Paine, of Sag Harbor, John Oliver, of Shields, Eng., William Humphries (the steward), of Philadelphia, and Thomas Liliston; the latter, however, went no farther than the cabin gangway, and then ran forward and turned in. According to his own story he did not think they would attempt to put their designs in execution, until he saw them actually descending into the cabin, having gone so far, to use his own expression, to show himself as brave as anv of them. But we believe he had not the smallest idea of assisting the villains. Comstock entered the cabin so silently as not to be perceived by the man at the helm, who was first apprised of his having begun the work of death, by the sound of a 24 heavy blow with an axe, which he distinctly heard.

The captain was asleep in a hammock, suspended in the cabin, his stateroom being uncomfortably warm ; Comstock approaching him with the axe, struck him a blow upon the head, which was nearly severed in two by the first stroke. After repeating the blow, he ran to Payne, who it seems was stationed with the before-mentioned boarding knife to attack the mate, as soon as the captain was killed. At this instant, Payne making a thrust at the mate, he awoke, and terrified, exclaimed, "What!

what! what! Is this Oh, Payne! Oh,

Comstock! Don't kill me, don't; have I not

always " Here Comstock interrupted him,

saying, "Yes ! you have always been a d — d rascal; you tell lies of me out of the ship, will you? It's a d — d good time to beg now, but you're too late;" here the mate sprang and grasped him by the throat. In the scuffle, the light which Comstock held in his hand was knocked out, and the axe fell from his hand, 25

The Globe Mutiny.

but the grasp of Mr. Beetle upon his throat did not prevent him from making Payne understand that his weapon was lost, who felt about until he found it, and having given it to Cornstock, he managed to strike Mr. Beetle a blow upon the head, which fractured his skull ; when he fell into the pantry where he lay groaning, until despatched by Comstock. The steward held a light at this time, while Oliver put in a blow as often as possible.

The second and third mates, fastened in their staterooms, lay in their berths listening, fearing to speak; and being ignorant of the numerical strength of the mutineers, and unarmed, thought it best to wait the dreadful issue, hoping that their lives might yet be spared.

Comstock, leaving a watch at the second mate's door, went upon deck to light another lamp at the binnacle, it having been again accidentally extinguished. He was there asked by his terrified brother, whose agony of mind we will not attempt to portray, if he intended to hurt Smith, the other boat-steerer. He replied that 26 he did ; and inquired where he was. George, fearing Smith would immediately be pursued, said he had not seen him. Comstock then perceiving his brother to be shedding tears, asked sternly, "What are you crying about?" "I am afraid," replied George, "that they will hurt me!" "I will hurt you," said he, "if you talk in that manner !"

But the work of death was not yet finished. Comstock took his light into the cabin, and made preparations for attacking the second and third mates, Mr. Fisher, and Mr. Lumbard. After loading two muskets, he fired one through the door, in the direction, as near as he could judge, of the officers, and then inquired if either was shot. Fisher replied, "Yes, I am shot in the mouth." Previous to his shooting Fisher, Lumbard asked if he was going to kill him. To which he answered with apparent unconcern, "Oh, no, I guess not."

They now opened the door, and Comstock, making a pass at Lumbard, missed him, and fell into the stateroom. Mr. Lumbard collared him, 27

The Globe Mutiny.

but he escaped from his hands. Mr. Fisher had got the gun, and actually presented the bayonet to the monster's heart. But Comstock assuring him that his life should be spared if he gave it up, he immediately did so, when Comstock immediately ran Mr. Lumbard through the body several times.

He then turned to Mr. Fisher, and told him there was no hope for him. "You have got to die," said he; "remember the scrape you got me into, when in company with the Enterprise, of Nantucket." The "scrape," alluded to was as follows: Comstock came up to Mr. Fisher to wrestle with him ; Fisher being the most athletic of the two, handled him with so much ease, that Comstock in a fit of passion struck him. At this Fisher seized him, and laid him upon the deck several times in pretty rough manner.

Comstock then made some violent threats, which Fisher paid no attention to, but which now fell upon his soul with all the horrors of reality. Finding his enemy deaf to his remon- 28 strances, and entreaties, he said, "If there is no hope, I will at least die like a man !" and having by order of Comstock, turned back to, he said in a firm voice, "I am ready !"

Comstock then put the muzzle of the gun to his head, and fired, which instantly put an end to his existence. Mr. Lumbard, during this time, was begging for life, although no doubt mortally wounded. Comstock turned to him and said, "I am a bloody man! I have a bloody hand and will be revenged!" and again ran him through the body with a bayonet. _ He then begged for a little water; "I'll give you water," said he, and once more plunging the weapon in his body, left him for dead.

Thus it appears that this more than demon murdered with his own hand, all the officers. Gladly would we wash from "memory's waste" all remembrance of that bloody night. The compassionate reader, however, whose heart sickens within him at the perusal, as does ours at the recital of this tale of woe, will not, we hope, disapprove our publishing these 29 melancholy facts to the world. As, through the boundless mercy of Providence, we have been restored to the bosom of our families and homes, we deemed it a duty we owe to the world, to record our "unvarnished tale."

The Globe Mutiny.

Chapter II

Smith, the other boat-steerer, who had been marked as one of the victims, on hearing the noise in the cabin, went aft, apprehending an altercation between the captain and some of the other officers, little dreaming that innocent blood was flowing in torrents. But what was his astonishment, when he beheld Comstock brandishing the boarding knife, and heard him exclaim, "I am the bloody man, and will have revenge!" Horror-struck, he hurried forward, and asked the crew in the forecastle, what he should do. Some urged him to secrete himself in the hold, others to go aloft until Comstock's rage should be abated ; but alas ! the reflection that the ship afforded no secure hiding place, determined him to confront the ringleader, and if he could not save his life by fair means, to sell 3* it dearly. He was soon called for by Cornstock, who upon meeting him, threw his bloody arms around his neck, and embracing him, said, "You are going to be with us, are you not?" The reader will discover the good policy of Smith when he unhesitatingly answered. "Oh, yes, I will do anything you require."

All hands were now called to make sail, and at the same time a light was set as a signal for the Lyra to tack ; while the Globe was kept upon the same tack, which very soon caused a separation of the two ships. All the reefs were turned out, top-gallant-sails set, and all sail made on the ship, the wind being quite light.

The mutineers then threw the body of the captain overboard, after wantonly piercing his bowels with a boarding knife, which was driven by an axe until the point protruded from his throat. In Mr. Beetle, the mate, the lamp of life had not entirely gone out, but he was committed to the deep.

Orders were next given to have the bodies of Mr. Fisher and Mr. Lumbard brought up. 32

A rope was fastened to Fisher's neck, by which he was hauled upon deck. A rope was made fast to Mr. Lumbard's feet, and in this way was he got upon deck, but when in the act of being thrown from the ship, he caught the plankshear, and appealed to Comstock, reminding him of his promise to save him, but in vain; for the monster forced him from his hold, and he fell into the sea. As he appeared to be yet capable of swimming, a boat was ordered to be lowered to pursue and finish him, fearing he might be picked up by the Lyra, which order was as soon countermanded as given, Comstock fearing, no doubt, a desertion of his murderous companions.

We will now present the reader with a journal of our passage to the Mulgrave Islands, for which group we shaped our course.

1824, January 26th. At 2 a.m. from being nearly calm a light breeze sprung up, which increased to a fresh breeze by 4 a.m. This day cleaned out the cabin, which was a scene of blood and destruction, of which the recollection at this day chills the blood in our veins. Every- 33 thing bearing marks of the murder was brought on deck and washed.

January 27th. These twenty-four hours commenced with moderate breezes from the eastward. Middle and latter part calm. Employed in cleaning the small arms, which were fifteen in number, and making cartridge boxes.

January 28th. This day, experienced fine weather, and light breezes from north by west. The black steward was hung for the following crime :

George Comstock was appointed steward after the mutiny, and business calling him into the cabin, he saw the former steward, now called the purser, engaged in loading a pistol. He asked him what he was doing that for. His reply was, "I have heard something very strange, and I am going to be ready for it." This information was immediately carried to Comstock, who called to Payne, now mate, and bid him follow him.

On entering the cabin they saw Humphries still standing with the pistol in his hand. On being demanded what he was going to do with it, he said he had heard something which made him afraid of his life.

Comstock told him if he had heard anything, that he ought to have come to him, and let him know, before he began loading pistols. He then demanded to know what he had heard. Humphries answered at first in a very suspicious and ambiguous manner, but at length said, "that Gilbert Smith, the boat-steerer who was saved, and Peter Kidder, were going to retake the ship." This appeared highly improbable, but they were summoned to attend a council at which Comstock presided, and asked if they had entertained any such intentions. They positively denied ever having had conversation upon the subject. All this took place in the evening. The next morning the parties were summoned, and a jury of two men called. Humphries, under guard of six men, armed with muskets, was arraigned, and Smith and Kidder, seated 35

The Globe Mutiny.

upon a chest near him. The prisoner was asked a few questions touching his intentions, which he answered, but low and indistinctly. The trial, if it may be so called, had progressed so far, when Comstock made a speech in the following words: "It appears that William Humphries has been accused guilty of a treacherous and base act, in loading a pistol for the purpose of shooting Mr. Payne and myself. Having been tried, the jury will now give in their verdict,, whether guilty or not guilty. If guilty he shall be hanged to a studding-sail boom, rigged out eight feet upon the fore-yard, but if found not guilty, Smith and Kidder shall be hung upon the aforementioned gallows." But the doom of Humphries had been sealed the night before, and kept secret from all except the jury, who returned a verdict of guilty. Preparations were immediately made for his execution. His watch was taken from him, and he was then taken forward and seated upon the rail, with a cap drawn over his face, and the rope placed round his neck.

Every man was ordered to take hold of the execution rope, to be ready to run him up when Comstock should give the signal, by ringing the bell.

He was now asked if he had anything to say, as he had but fourteen seconds to live. He began by saying, "Little did I think I was born

to come to this " the bell struck, and he was

immediately swung to the yard-arm. He died without a struggle, and after he had hung a few minutes, the rope was cut to let him fall overboard, but getting entangled aloft the body was towed some distance alongside, when a runner hook (a large hook used when hoisting in the blubber) was attached to it, to sink it, when the rope was again cut and the body disappeared. His chest was now overhauled, and sixteen dollars in specie was found, which he had taken from the captain's trunk. Thus ended the life of one of the mutineers, while the blood of innocent victims was scarcely washed from his hands, much less the guilty stain from his soul.

February 7th. These twenty-four hours commenced with thick, squally weather. Middle part clear and fine weather. Hove to at 2 a.m. and at 6 made sail, and steered west by south. At half past eight, made an island ahead, one of the Kingsmill group. Stood in with the land and received a number of canoes alongside, the natives, however, having nothing to sell us but a few beads of their own manufacture. We saw some cocoanut and other trees upon the shore, and discovered many of the natives upon the beach and some dogs. The principal food of these islanders is a kind of bread fruit, which they pound very fine and mix with fish.